91Ӱ

Lipid News

Proteins and lipids —
a complicated relationship?

Eva Sevcsik Gerhard J. Schütz
By Eva Sevcsik and Gerhard J. Schütz
Jan. 1, 2017

Researchers have been discussing for many years the role of the lipid matrix in regulating the activity and the organization of membrane proteins. A variety of effects have been singled out and studied qualitatively and quantitatively in model systems. However, the applicability of those results to living cells is — in many cases — unsatisfactory. Here, we would like to make the point that the complexity of the lipid–protein matrix in cells alters the physico-chemical mechanisms of protein–lipid interactions to an unknown extent when compared to model systems.

In a complex environment, hydrophobic mismatch may cause a protein to fluctuate between different states: (from left to right) hydrophobic mismatch, protein aggregation, protein tilting and recruitment of long-chain lipids.SCHEMATIC PROVIDED BY EVA SEVCSIK AND GERHARD J . SCHÜTZ

We shall discriminate between global and local mechanisms. Global mechanisms are mediated by lipid-bilayer properties; local mechanisms denote a direct molecular interaction between a protein and a lipid molecule. Examples of global effects include curvature, hydrophobic mismatch and preferential partitioning in phase-separated membranes (“rafts”) (1–3); examples of local mechanisms are the direct binding of cholesterol to CRAC domains (4) or of phosphatidylinositol 4,5-bisphosphate to protein subunits (5).

Formally, we may characterize a protein via its chemical potential µ, with the values for two different functional or structural states, µ1 and µ2. If (R is the gas constant, T the temperature), a pronounced preference for one of the two states will occur. In contrast, for , we expect no preferred state.

Most of the data for global mechanisms come from studies on simple, well-defined model systems, which allow for specifically addressing individual parameters. To emphasize the effects, such model systems usually are selected to achieve substantial contrast between µ1 and µ2. Examples would be the partitioning of proteins into ordered versus disordered phases in phase-separated lipid bilayers (6) or the recruitment of proteins to lipid vesicles with different curvature (7). Also, for local mechanisms, chemical potentials are the appropriate means of quantitating a protein’s state: µ1 denotes the lipid-bound state, µ2 the unbound state, and the equilibrium binding constant.

In cell membranes, however, a plethora of lipid species with varying properties, such as different head groups, acyl chain lengths and degrees of saturation, increases the complexity of the situation. The consequence for global mechanisms will be myriad chemical potentials describing the possible states of the protein, which can be approximated by a continuous energy landscape: Proteins essentially fluctuate between the different states. In some cases, cells may amplify the difference in chemical potential by de novo assembly of membrane structures, such as clathrin-coated pits, so that the partitioning or activity contrast will become more pronounced.

Also, in the case of local mechanisms, a variety of lipids may be able to interact with the protein of interest, potentially with only slightly different affinities. This leads to the recruitment of specific lipid species to the vicinity of the protein and an essentially continuous distribution of chemical potentials. Again, in some cases, preferred interactions of the protein with one type of lipid occur, yielding additional discrete values of µ.

What would be the consequences of a continuous distribution of chemical potentials? There would be no clear-cut states of a protein. For example, hydrophobic mismatch, on a stochastic basis, may lead transiently to demixing of the protein, the recruitment of a shell of long-chain lipids and membrane curvature. The system would fluctuate between these scenarios. Only in cases where the energy continuum splits up, or where distinct extra-states exist, can we expect distinct states of a protein. In conclusion, studies of well-defined model systems certainly help our understanding of fundamental physico-chemical properties, but the complexity of the live cell environment provides many more options to minimize the global energy of the system.


References

  1. Milovanovic, D. et al. Nat. Commun.6, 5984 (2015).
  2. McMahon, H.T. & Boucrot, E. J. Cell. Sci.128, 1065 – 1070 (2015).
  3. Van Meer, G. et al. Nat. Rev. Mol. Cell Biol.9, 112 – 124 (2008).
  4. Fantini, J. & Barrantes, F.J., Front. Physiol.4, 31 (2013).
  5. Hamilton, P.J. et al. Nat. Chem. Biol.10, 582 – 589 (2014).
  6. Dietrich, C. et al. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA98, 10642 – 10647 (2001).
  7. Hatzakis, N.S. et al. Nat. Chem. Biol.5, 835 – 841 (2009).

Enjoy reading 91ӰToday?

Become a member to receive the print edition four times a year and the digital edition monthly.

Learn more
Eva Sevcsik
Eva Sevcsik

Eva Sevcsik is a researcher at the Institute of Applied Physics at TU Wien in Austria.

Gerhard J. Schütz
Gerhard J. Schütz

Gerhard J. Schütz leads the biophysics group at the Institute of Applied Physics at TU Wien.

Related articles

Elusive zebrafish enzyme in lipid secretion
Isabel Casas & Emily Ulrich
Cholesterol lures in coronavirus
Marissa Locke Rottinghaus
A surprising modification lowers the lipid binding affinity of a membrane trafficking protein
Jefferson Knight, Colin T. Shearn & Cisloynny Beauchamp–Pérez

Get the latest from 91ӰToday

Enter your email address, and we’ll send you a weekly email with recent articles, interviews and more.

Latest in Science

Science highlights or most popular articles

Receptor antagonist reduces age-related bone loss in mice
Journal News

Receptor antagonist reduces age-related bone loss in mice

Aug. 6, 2025

Receptor antagonist reduces bone loss and promotes osteoblast activity in aging mice, highlighting its potential to treat osteoporosis. Read more about this recent JBC paper.

Engineered fusion protein targets kiwifruit pathogen
Journal News

Engineered fusion protein targets kiwifruit pathogen

Aug. 6, 2025

Synthetic protein selectively kills kiwifruit pathogen, offering a promising biocontrol strategy for agriculture. Read more about this recent JBC paper.

Pathogen-derived enzyme engineered for antibiotic design
Journal News

Pathogen-derived enzyme engineered for antibiotic design

Aug. 6, 2025

Engineered variants of a bacterial enzyme developed at the University at Buffalo accept larger substrates, paving the way for new acinetobactin-based antimicrobials. Read more about this recent JBC paper.

Omega-3 fats linked to healthy aging and improved heart metabolism
Journal News

Omega-3 fats linked to healthy aging and improved heart metabolism

Aug. 1, 2025

Scientists from the University of Iowa find that a diet high in polyunsaturated fatty acids from fish oil increases cardiac triglyceride uptake and improves insulin sensitivity. Read more about this recent JLR study.

RA patient blood reveals joint innerworkings
Journal News

RA patient blood reveals joint innerworkings

July 25, 2025

Researchers in the Netherlands use mass spectrometry to compare the proteome of plasma and synovial fluid in rheumatoid arthritis patients and find a correlation. Read more about this recent paper in Molecular & Cellular Proteomics.

Hope for a cure hangs on research
Essay

Hope for a cure hangs on research

July 17, 2025

Amid drastic proposed cuts to biomedical research, rare disease families like Hailey Adkisson’s fight for survival and hope. Without funding, science can’t “catch up” to help the patients who need it most.